All American Catering Menu

Hungry Hoosiers can end their search for home-cooked catering menus at All American Catering. Serving Indianapolis, IN, and the surrounding areas, we combine crave-worthy cooking and detailed-driven service to ensure your next private event leaves a lasting impression on every guest.

From corporate events and employee retreats to weddings and private events, our full-service catering options feature dishes made fresh to order in our local kitchens. Every recipe relies on real, fresh ingredients to bring delicious Midwestern dishes to your plate at an affordable price.

Check out our full Indianapolis catering menu below or call us for a custom quote today!

Not Available for Weddings

All American Grill Menu

Fire up your guests with an authentic picnic atmosphere tailored to your corporate event. We’ll set up our grills directly at your venue and create a dining experience you will never forget.

Vegetarian Option Upon Request | Large Group Pricing Available

ENTREES

Choose Two (2)

Fire-Grilled Hamburgers

1/4 lb. Freshly Grilled Hamburger Patties

Freshly Grilled All-Beef Hot Dogs

Grilled BBQ Seasoned Boneless Chicken Breast

Grilled Boneless Chicken Breast Marinated in BBQ Spice Rub

WITH ALL THE FIXIN’S

SIDE DISH OPTIONS

Choose Three (3)

COLD SIDE OPTION
  • Amish Macaroni Salad
  • Zesty Chipotle Coleslaw
  • Watermelon Lollipops
  • Loaded Potato Salad
  • Broccoli Cheddar Pasta Salad
  • Creamy Tropical Fruit Salad
HOT SIDE OPTION
  • Baked White Cheddar Mac & Cheese 
  • Griddled Red Potatoes w/ Onions & Peppers 
  • Smokey Baked Beans 
  • Hoosier Buttered Corn 
  • Country Style Green Beans w/ Bacon & Onions 
  • House Kettle Chips 
  • Grilled Corn on the Cob 
  • Grilled Vegetable Medley

All American BBQ Menu

Our smoked favorites steal the show. While we offer swift catering services, we take our time seasoning and smoking all the meats – low and slow – for a tender, flavorful result.

Vegetarian Option Upon Request | Large Group Pricing Available

ENTREES

Choose Two (2)

Slow Smoked Pulled Chicken

A Blend of White & Dark Meat Chicken, Slow Smoked for 3 Hours Until It Falls Apart

Tender Hickory Smoked Pulled Pork

Tender Seasoned Pork Shoulder, Hickory Smoked for 12 Hours

Texas-Style Smoked Chuck Roast

Chopped Chuck Roast Seasoned with a Coffee & Black Pepper Rub, Slow Smoked for 16 Hours, Served in Rich Au Jus

WITH ALL THE FIXIN’S

SIDE DISH OPTIONS

Choose Three (3)

COLD SIDE OPTION
  • Amish Macaroni Salad 
  • Zesty Chipotle Coleslaw 
  • Watermelon Lollipops 
  • Loaded Potato Salad 
  • Broccoli Cheddar Pasta Salad 
  • Creamy Tropical Fruit Salad
Hot SIDE OPTION
  • Baked White Cheddar Mac & Cheese 
  • Griddled Red Potatoes w/ Onions & Peppers 
  • Smokey Baked Beans 
  • Hoosier Buttered Corn 
  • Country Style Green Beans w/ Bacon & Onions 
  • House Kettle Chips 
  • Grilled Corn on the Cob 
  • Griddled Vegetable Medley
  • Jalapeno Creamed Corn

All American Banquet Packages

All Packages are Served with a Side Salad of your Choice.

Freshly made Desserts are Sold Separately.

PACKAGE A

Cajun Smoked Pork Loin

Marinated with a Blend of Cajun Spices & Garlic, Served with Apple Cider Sauce

Southern Baked Chicken Thighs

Boneless Chicken Thighs, Seasoned with a Smokey Blend of Fresh Herbs & Spices, Caramelized Honey Glaze

White Cheddar Mashed Potatoes with Chives

Yukon Gold Mashed Potatoes with White Cheddar, Topped with Sliced Chives

Griddled Vegetable Medley

A Blend of Green Beans, Peppers, Pearl Onions & Carrots

Dinner Rolls with Butter

PACKAGE B

Hoosier Chicken & Dumplings

Tender Chicken, House Dumplings Stewed in Rich Chicken Broth

Yankee Pot Roast

Slow Braised Chuck Roast, Savory Pan Jus, Garnished with Braised Red Potatoes & Baby Carrots

Homestyle Mashed Potatoes

Creamy Mashed Russet Potatoes, Served with Brown Gravy

Country Style Green Beans

Slow Cooked Cut Green Beans with Applewood Bacon & Yellow Onions

Dinner Rolls with Butter

PACKAGE C

Fried Boneless Chicken Breast & Thighs

Seasoned with our Secret Chicken Seasoning and Fried to Perfection!

Mashed Potatoes with White Gravy

Freshly Whipped Potatoes and Butter Served with our Signature White Peppered Gravy

Southern Style Green Beans

Slow Cooked Green Beans Topped with Bacon, Ham, Onions, and Seasoning

All American Coleslaw

Rich and Creamy Blend of Shredded Cabbage and our Signature Dressing

Fried Biscuits and Apple Butter

Cinnamon-fried biscuits with a Side of Savory Apple Butter

PACKAGE D

Grilled Fajita Chicken

Grilled Chicken Breast Strips Marinated in a Blend of Mexican Spices

Grilled Steak Fajitas

Grilled Strips of Thinly Sliced Skirt Steak Marinated in a Blend of Mexican Spices

Sautéed Peppers & Onions

Spiced Yellow Onions with Red & Green Bell Peppers

Spanish Rice

Zesty Rice with Tomatoes and Bell Peppers

Refried Beans

Refried Beans Topped with Cheddar & Monterey Jack Cheese

Flour Tortillas, Sour Cream & Pico de Gallo

PACKAGE E

Grilled Chicken with Baked Penne Alfredo

Italian Herb Marinated Grilled Chicken Strips, Penne Pasta with Roasted Garlic & Parmesan Sauce, Topped with Mozzarella Cheese

Pasta Primavera

A Blend of Garden Vegetables, Rigatoni Pasta, Zested Lemon, Basil Pesto, Shaved Parmesan & Fresh Herbs

Grilled Italian Sausage

Mild Grilled Italian Sausage Links, Served with Sautéed Bell Peppers, Yellow Onions, and Tomato Basil Sauce

Garlic Parmesan Roasted Red Potatoes

Red Skinned Potatoes, Garlic, Butter, Parmesan Cheese, Blend of Fresh Herbs & Spices

Mediterranean Grilled Vegetables

A Blend of Grilled Eggplant, Zucchini, and Bell Peppers

Garlic Toast

SIDE SALADS

Choose 1 Per Package

Garden Salad

Chopped Iceberg Lettuce, Shredded Carrot, Red Cabbage, Roma Tomatoes, Sliced Cucumber, Red Radishes, Served with Ranch and Italian Dressing

Caesar Salad

Chopped Romaine Lettuce, Tossed in Creamy Caesar Dressing, with Parmesan Cheese & Croutons

American Chopped Salad

Chopped Romaine Lettuce, Thin Sliced Red Onion, Roma Tomatoes, Boiled Eggs, Corn, Shredded Carrot, Monterey Jack Cheese, Served with Ranch and Italian Dressing

Taste of Italy Salad

Chopped Iceberg Lettuce, Pepperoncini, Red Onion, Roma Tomatoes, Bell Peppers, Black Olives, Diced Provolone Cheese, Croutons, Served with Ranch and Italian Dressing

PACKAGE A

Cluckett’s Fried Chicken

Boneless chicken breast and thighs seasoned with our Secret Chicken Seasoning and Fried to Perfection

Mashed Potatoes with White Gravy

Freshly Whipped Potatoes and Butter (GF) Served with our Signature White Peppered Gravy. (Not GF)

Southern Style Green Beans (GF)

Slow Cooked Green Beans Topped with Bacon, Ham, Onions, and Seasoning

All American Coleslaw (GF)

Rich and Creamy Blend of Shredded Cabbage and our Signature Dressing

Freshly Made Buttermilk Biscuits with Butter

PACKAGE B

Cajun Smoked Pork Loin (GF)

Marinated with a Blend of Cajun Spices & Garlic, Served with Apple Cider Sauce

Southern Baked Chicken Thighs (GF)

Boneless Chicken Thighs, Seasoned with a Smokey Blend of Fresh Herbs & Spices, Caramelized Honey Glaze

White Cheddar Mashed Potatoes with Chives (GF)

Yukon Gold Mashed Potatoes with White Cheddar, Topped with Sliced Chives

Griddled Vegetable Medley (GF)

A Blend of Green Beans, Peppers, Pearl Onions & Carrots

Freshly Made Buttermilk Biscuits with Butter

PACKAGE C

Grilled Fajita Chicken (GF)

Grilled Chicken Breast Strips Marinated in a Blend of Mexican Spices

Grilled Steak Fajitas (GF)

Grilled Strips of Thinly Sliced Skirt Steak Marinated in a Blend of Mexican Spices

Sautéed Peppers & Onions (GF)

Spiced Yellow Onions with Red & Green Bell Peppers

Spanish Rice (GF)

Zesty Rice with Tomatoes and Bell Peppers

Refried Beans (GF)

Refried Beans Topped with Cheddar & Monterey Jack Cheese

Flour Tortillas (GF), Sour Cream (GF) & Pico de Gallo (GF)

PACKAGE D

Hoosier Chicken & Dumplings

Tender Chicken, House Dumplings Stewed in Rich Chicken Broth

Yankee Pot Roast (GF)

Slow Braised Chuck Roast, Savory Pan Jus, Garnished with Braised Red Potatoes & Baby Carrots

Homestyle Mashed Potatoes

Creamy Mashed Russet Potatoes (GF), Served with Brown Gravy (Not GF)

Country Style Green Beans (GF)

Slow Cooked Cut Green Beans with Applewood Bacon & Yellow Onions

Freshly Made Buttermilk Biscuits with Butter

PACKAGE E

Grilled Chicken with Baked Penne Alfredo

Italian Herb Marinated Grilled Chicken Strips, Penne Pasta with Roasted Garlic & Parmesan Sauce, Topped with Mozzarella Cheese

Pasta Primavera

A Blend of Garden Vegetables, Rigatoni Pasta, Zested Lemon, Basil Pesto, Shaved Parmesan & Fresh Herbs

Grilled Italian Sausage (GF)

Mild Grilled Italian Sausage Links, Served with Sautéed Bell Peppers, Yellow Onions, and Tomato Basil Sauce

Garlic Parmesan Roasted Red Potatoes (GF)

Red Skinned Potatoes, Garlic, Butter, Parmesan Cheese, Blend of Fresh Herbs & Spices

Mediterranean Grilled Vegetables (GF)

A Blend of Grilled Eggplant, Zucchini, and Bell Peppers

Garlic Toast

SIDE SALADS

Choose 1 Per Package

Garden Salad (GF)

Chopped Iceberg Lettuce, Shredded Carrot, Red Cabbage, Roma Tomatoes, Sliced Cucumber, Red Radishes, Served with Ranch and Italian Dressing

Caesar Salad

Chopped Romaine Lettuce, Tossed in Creamy Caesar Dressing, with Parmesan Cheese & Croutons

American Chopped Salad (GF)

Chopped Romaine Lettuce, Thin Sliced Red Onion, Roma Tomatoes, Boiled Eggs, Corn, Shredded Carrot, Monterey Jack Cheese, Served with Ranch and Italian Dressing

Taste of Italy Salad

Chopped Iceberg Lettuce, Pepperoncini, Red Onion, Roma Tomatoes, Bell Peppers, Black Olives, Diced Provolone Cheese, Croutons, Served with Ranch and Italian Dressing

Desserts

Savor the meal by adding any of these sweet, freshly-made desserts to your menu package.

All desserts sold separately.

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Ghirardelli Triple Chocolate Brownies

Warm Fruit Cobbler

Choice of: Apple, Cherry, or Peach

Vanilla Ice Cream Cups

Sheet Cakes

Choice of: Chocolate Cake, Yellow Cake, Carrot Cake, Red Velvet Cake, White Cake, or Cheesecake Bars with Cherry Topping
shutterstock_1140025022

Á La Carte Appetizers

Fruit Tray (Serves 50)

Fresh Cut Cantaloupe, Honeydew & Pineapple, Garnished with Red & Green Grapes and Seasonal Berries, Served with Marshmallow Fruit Dip

Domestic Cheese Tray (Serves 50)

An Assortment of Domestic Cheese Cubes, Served with Assorted Crackers

Vegetable Tray (Serves 50)

Fresh Broccoli, Cauliflower, Baby Carrots, Bell Peppers, Grape Tomatoes & Cucumbers, Served with Buttermilk Ranch Dipping Sauce

Teriyaki BBQ Meatballs (Serves 50)

1/2 oz Savory Meatballs, Simmered in a Sweet and Spicy Teriyaki BBQ Sauce

Sweet BBQ Cocktail Sausages (Serves 50)

Mini Cocktail Sausages, Simmered in a Sweet BBQ Sauce

Cheeseball with Crackers (Serves 50)

Chipped Dried Beef, Cream Cheese, Scallions, a Hint of Horseradish & Fresh Herbs, Served with Assorted Crackers

Smoked Chicken Wings (Serves 50)

Lightly Smoked Chicken Wings, Served with a choice of Tangy BBQ or Mild Buffalo Sauce

Loaded Potato Skins (Serves 50)

Golden Brown Potato Boats, Filled with Cheddar Cheese, Bacon Bits & Scallions, Served with Southwest Ranch Dipping Sauce

Contact All American Catering Today

When it comes to your next event, don’t settle for anything less than the best.

With more than 40 years of combined experience in catering private events in Central Indiana, our local catering company is here to help. From cooking delectable dishes from scratch to set up and service, we have the catering services you need to pull your event off without a hitch.

Trust us to deliver mouthwatering meals, always on time. Contact All American Catering to get a quote for your next Indianapolis catering order today.